Paper · Jun 4, 2022

A numerical stability analysis of mean curvature flow of noncompact hypersurfaces with Type-II curvature blowup: II

David Garfinkle, James Isenberg, Dan Knopf, Haotian Wu

math.DGWider flowsarXiv:2206.01890
PDF Abstract page

As on arXiv

Abstract

In previous work [GIKW21], we have presented evidence from numerical simulations that the Type-II singularities of mean curvature flow (MCF) of rotationally-symmetric, complete, noncompact embedded hypersurfaces constructed in [IW19, IWZ21] are stable. More precisely, it is shown in that paper that for small rotationally-symmetric perturbations of initial embeddings near the "tip", numerical simulations of MCF of such initial embeddings develop the same Type-II singularities with the same "bowl soliton" blowup behaviors in a neighborhood of the singularity. It is also shown in that work that for small rotationally-symmetric perturbations of the initial embeddings that are sufficiently far away from the tip, MCF develops Type-I "neckpinch" singularities. In this work, we again use numerical simulations to show that MCF subject to initial perturbations that are not rotationally symmetric behaves asymptotically like it does for rotationally-symmetric perturbations. In particular, if we impose sinusoidal angular dependence on the initial embeddings, we find that for perturbations near the tip, evolutions by MCF asymptotically lose their angular dependence – becoming round – and develop Type-II bowl soliton singularities. As well, if we impose sinusoidal angular dependence on the initial embeddings for perturbations sufficiently far from the tip, the angular dependence again disappears as Type-I neckpinch singularities develop. The numerical analysis carried out in this work is an adaptation of the "overlap" method introduced in [GIKW21] and permits angular dependence.

Comments: 17 pages, 13 figures. Comments are welcome!

Its neighbourhood

Connected papers

The 8 papers on this site closest to this one, judged by the topics they share, the words and phrases in their titles and abstracts, and their authors. They are not its citations, but a map of the work around it. Papers here go back to 2021, plus the canon.

Connected papers This paper in the centre and the 8 papers closest to it around it, in date order clockwise from the top. The closer a paper sits to the centre, the stronger the connection. This paper Convergence stability for Ricci flow on manifolds with bounded geometry (Eric Bahuaud, Christine Guenther, James Isenberg et al., 2023)3Bahuaud 2023 Stability of piecewise flat Ricci flow (Rory Conboye, 2023)5Conboye 2023 Asymptotic behavior of unstable perturbations of the Fubini-Study metric in Ricci flow (David Garfinkle, James Isenberg, Dan Knopf et al., 2024)1Garfinkle 2024 Self-shrinkers whose asymptotic cones fatten (Daniel Ketover, 2024)8Ketover 2024 Local singularities of compact multiply warped Ricci flow solutions (James Isenberg, Dan Knopf, Zilu Ma et al., 2025)2Isenberg 2025 Mean curvature flow near a peanut solution (Sigurd Angenent, Panagiota Daskalopoulos and Natasa Sesum, 2025)4Angenent 2025 Comparison Theorems for the Profile Curve Equation of Rotationally Symmetric Self-Shrinkers (Peng Peng, 2026)6Peng 2026 Noise-induced stabilization of Schwarzschild–AdS black holes under stochastic Ricci flow (Jihui Wang, Matteo Lulli and Antonino Marciano, 2026)7Wang 2026
Closer to the centre: more closely connected. Clockwise from the top: oldest to newest. Ricci flowWider flowsalso connected to each other
  1. Asymptotic behavior of unstable perturbations of the Fubini-Study metric in Ricci flow

    David Garfinkle, James Isenberg, Dan Knopf et al. PDF

    Topics Numerics & visualization, Singularities, Stability & uniqueness · Same authors David Garfinkle, James Isenberg, Dan Knopf · Shared terms “numerical simulations”, “perturbation”

  2. Local singularities of compact multiply warped Ricci flow solutions

    James Isenberg, Dan Knopf, Zilu Ma et al. PDF

    Topics Rotational symmetry & warped products, Boundaries & non-compact, Singularities · Same authors James Isenberg, Dan Knopf

  3. Convergence stability for Ricci flow on manifolds with bounded geometry

    Eric Bahuaud, Christine Guenther, James Isenberg et al. PDF

    Topics Rotational symmetry & warped products, Boundaries & non-compact, Singularities · Same author James Isenberg · Shared terms “rotationally symmetric”, “sufficiently”

  4. Mean curvature flow near a peanut solution

    Sigurd Angenent, Panagiota Daskalopoulos and Natasa SesumWider flows PDF

    Topics Self-shrinkers & translators, Singularities, Stability & uniqueness · Shared terms “neckpinch singularities”, “perturbation”, “bowl soliton”

  5. Stability of piecewise flat Ricci flow

    Rory Conboye PDF

    Topics Numerics & visualization, Stability & uniqueness · Shared terms “stability analysis”, “numerical simulations”, “adaptation”

  6. Comparison Theorems for the Profile Curve Equation of Rotationally Symmetric Self-Shrinkers

    Peng PengWider flows PDF

    Topics Rotational symmetry & warped products, Self-shrinkers & translators, Singularities · Shared terms “rotationally symmetric”

  7. Noise-induced stabilization of Schwarzschild–AdS black holes under stochastic Ricci flow

    Jihui Wang, Matteo Lulli and Antonino Marciano PDF

    Topics Numerics & visualization, Rotational symmetry & warped products, Stability & uniqueness · Shared terms “symmetric perturbations”, “simulations”, “numerical”

  8. Self-shrinkers whose asymptotic cones fatten

    Daniel KetoverWider flows PDF

    Topics Numerics & visualization, Self-shrinkers & translators, Boundaries & non-compact · Shared terms “numerical”, “sufficiently”

Read around it

Background reading

The guides for the topics of this paper: what each idea is, why it matters, and the papers to read first.

In the guidebook

  1. 6D.11
    Computing Geometric FlowsBook 6D · Diffusions, Finance and Computation

    Numerical curve shortening and mean curvature flow, level sets and phase fields, discrete Ricci flow on surfaces and in conformal mapping, rotationally symmetric neckpinches, and what computation has taught about singularities.

  2. 6A.13
    Self-Similar Variables and MonotonicityBook 6A · The Heat Equation and Its Relatives

    Changing variables so that self-similar solutions stand still: convergence to the Gaussian, Giga–Kohn blow-up, Gaussian-weighted monotonicity formulas, frequency functions, and the blow-up logic of Huisken, Struwe and Perelman.

  3. 6C.8
    Monotonicity, ε-Regularity and Tangent ConesBook 6C · Nonlinear PDE: Variational and Geometric Methods

    Monotonicity formulas for minimal surfaces and harmonic maps, small energy implies smoothness, bubble trees, tangent cones and dimension reduction, with soap films, liquid crystals and pseudolocality.