In briefRicci flow beyond closed manifolds: complete non-compact spaces, manifolds with boundary, and asymptotically flat or hyperbolic ends. Existence, uniqueness and behaviour at infinity all need new ideas there.
∂tg=−2Ric(g),Msup∣Rm(g0)∣<∞
225papers
13in the last 30 days
7key references
Guide
In depth
What it is
On a closed manifold, Ricci flow always exists for a short time and is unique. Outside that setting, both statements need care.
Complete non-compact manifolds. Shi (1989) proved short-time existence when the curvature is bounded, together with his derivative estimates. Chen and Zhu proved uniqueness in that class. Without a curvature bound, existence is a hard problem. Topping solved it completely on surfaces with instantaneously complete flows. In dimension three there are results under lower Ricci bounds (Simon–Topping, Hochard).
Manifolds with boundary. Ricci flow has no single natural boundary condition. Shen studied umbilic boundaries. Gianniotis proved well-posedness when the conformal class and mean curvature of the boundary are prescribed.
Asymptotic ends. Oliynyk and Woolgar showed that Ricci flow preserves asymptotic flatness and keeps the ADM mass constant, which makes the flow a tool for questions from general relativity. Asymptotically hyperbolic and conical ends appear in the study of expanders and shrinkers.
Why it matters
Singularity models are non-compact, so every blow-up argument happens on complete manifolds. Many applications — to general relativity, to Kähler cones and resolutions, and to gluing constructions — need flows on spaces with ends or boundary. Understanding what happens at infinity is often the whole difficulty.
Where it stands
Active directions include:
existence of flows from complete metrics with unbounded curvature in dimension three and above;
boundary conditions that make the flow useful, for example for fill-in and quasi-local mass problems;
mass and other asymptotic invariants along the flow;
flows from asymptotically conical metrics that resolve cone singularities.
We prove that a complete noncompact gradient shrinking Ricci soliton of dimension at least two is a finite quotient of an Einstein cylinder if its scalar curvature is bounded below by the cylindrical value. The corresponding pointwise strict bound implies compactness. We also establish one-endedness criteria using curvature information at critical points of the potential, including degenerate ones, and obtain sharp one-endedness and rigidity results under global Ricci norm bounds.
We study the behaviour of the conjugate radius under the Ricci flow on complete noncompact manifolds. We show that if (Mn,g(t))t∈[0,T] is a complete Ricci flow with nonnegative scalar curvature at t=0, the initial metric is parabolic and not Ricci-flat, and the Einstein tensor Ric−21Rg is bounded above, then parabolicity is preserved along the flow and the conjugate radius of g(t) is finite for every t∈(0,T]. As an application, we prove that a complete noncompact gradient shrinking Ricci soliton whose volume growth is subquadratic, in the sense that liminfr→∞\Vol(B(p,r))/r2=0, has finite conjugate radius.
We prove strong uniqueness of tangent flows at the first singular time of a closed Ricci flow when one tangent flow is generated by a complete smooth asymptotically conical Ricci shrinker. The modified flow converges to this shrinker in a fixed gauge, with quantitative estimates on expanding domains. The main ingredients are a Łojasiewicz-Simon inequality for Perelman's entropy, based on the global weighted divergence-free gauge constructed in the preceding paper, and estimates controlling the geometric radius under Ricci flow.
We show that the blowdown shrinking Ricci soliton of Feldman, Ilmanen and Knopf is strictly dynamically stable in the following strong local sense: (1) The Ricci flow from every metric on a closed 4-manifold containing a region close to a rescaling of a sufficiently large compact subset of the soliton in either orientation and with controlled geometry elsewhere develops a singularity with unique tangent flow modeled on the soliton. (2) The singular time slice has an isolated conical singularity, and by Gianniotis-Schulze the flow can be continued by blowing down a sphere of self-intersection ±1. (3) On a closed 4-manifold, the set of metrics whose Ricci flows have their first singularity modeled on the soliton is C14-open. It is nonempty if and only if the manifold contains a sphere of self-intersection ±1. (4) The soliton is strongly rigid among shrinking Ricci solitons. As applications, we construct C14-open sets of initial data whose Ricci flows perform any prescribed ordered sequence of blowdowns. (1) Every closed simply connected smooth 4-manifold, including spin and exotic examples, can be reached by Ricci flow from a standard kCP2#ℓCP2, through finitely many blowdown singularities. (2) On the standard 2CP2#9CP2, there are infinitely many open sets of initial metrics whose Ricci flows, after a single blowdown, reach pairwise nondiffeomorphic manifolds. The proof uses the spectral analysis of Naff and the second author and deals with the gauge-fixing problem along Ricci flow through a Ważewski argument inspired by Stolarski. We also use Bamler-Lai's PDE-ODI principle. Except for continuation (requiring nonnegative curvature of the asymptotic cone), all results apply to linearly stable nonflat asymptotically conical shrinkers in all dimensions.
We classify complete, non-compact, simply connected, irreducible four-dimensional steady gradient Ricci solitons that are globally conformally Kähler and have an isoparametric potential. The steady Ricci solitons are U(2)-invariant nuts on R4, including the Bryant and Cao solitons, and bolts on S2×R2 and on O(−m)→CP1. For each m≥3 there is exactly one non-collapsed bolt. A key step, valid for Ricci solitons of every sign, is that away from the locally conformally flat case, the conformal factor is aligned with the potential function, which yields cohomogeneity-one symmetry.
We develop the weighted Sobolev and Hölder analysis needed to study perturbations of complete asymptotically conical (AC) Ricci shrinkers. Weighted elliptic estimates yield a global weighted divergence-free slice in spaces that retain the asymptotic data at infinity. As a geometric application, we prove pointed Gromov-Hausdorffrigidity of nontrivial AC shrinkers with vanishing infinitesimal solitonic deformation space.
We construct closed mean curvature flows with arbitrarily large genus increase in every smooth Riemannian three-manifold, giving counterexamples to Ilmanen's genus-reduction conjecture. We prove that a compact hypersurface with a single isolated conical singularity and a power rate of convergence to its cone admits a mean curvature flow whose forward rescaled limit is a prescribed expander in the tangent space at the singular point, smoothly asymptotic to that cone. Combining this theorem with closed mean curvature flows with prescribed tangent flows (arXiv:2405.15577, arXiv:2607.23879) and the noncompact counterexample (arXiv:2605.09657) gives the desired examples.
We describe the self-expanders of the mean curvature flow in Rp+q+2 invariant under O(p+1)×O(q+1). Apart from the Clifford minimal cone, every such hypersurface is complete, proper and noncompact, and belongs to one of three families: two one-parameter families of embedded hypersurfaces diffeomorphic to Rp+1×Sq or to Rq+1×Sp, whose profile curves leave an axis, and a two-parameter family diffeomorphic to R×Sp×Sq, parametrized by the point of the profile curve closest to the origin, which is the generic family: its set of initial conditions is open and of full measure in the phase space. Every end is asymptotically conical, with explicit decay rates, and every such hypersurface has Euclidean volume growth. A profile curve of the third family has at most one loop, and the point of the curve closest to the origin lies on that loop.
We describe the global structure of the self-shrinkers of the mean curvature flow in Rp+q+2 invariant under O(p+1)×O(q+1), without assuming properness or embeddedness. The main tool is a pair of piecewise monotone quantities along the profile curves, in the spirit of Hsiang's analysis of constant mean curvature hypersurfaces. We prove that every such self-shrinker other than the two invariant cylinders intersects both of them transversely, and all of them except the Clifford minimal cone are complete. Apart from those of the cylinders, each end is either asymptotic to a cone or meets both cylinders infinitely many times. Consequently, a complete noncompact example is proper if and only if all its ends are asymptotically conical, and this is equivalent to polynomial volume growth, to finite entropy, and to finitely many intersections with the cylinders. The reduced flow preserves a finite measure, and for almost every initial condition the profile curve is either closed or generates a complete nonproper self-shrinker of infinite entropy. We also bound the winding of the profile curve by its number of cylinder crossings and localize its self-intersections.
Let compact RCD(κ,N) spaces converge in the measured Gromov–Hausdorff sense, and suppose that they have (δ,ρ)-Reifenberg local covers for one fixed ρ>0, with ∣κ∣ρ2≤1 and δ small. We prove that, along a subsequence, the spaces are singular fibrations over the limit: their canonical frame spaces converge to a topological manifold with a locally linear action of O(n) whose quotient is the limit; for large indices the frame spaces fibre over this manifold, by maps that commute with O(n), with fibres homeomorphic to nilmanifolds; and the induced maps to the limit are, near every point, quotients of products by the isotropy group, with fibres homeomorphic to infranilmanifolds. As applications, we extend a fibration theorem of Honda and Zhang to non-smooth RCD spaces whose local covers have injectivity radius bounded below, and we show that for aspherical spaces the isotropy groups are finite, the fibre groups inject into the fundamental groups, and the limit is the quotient of a contractible manifold by a proper cocompact action; under Rong's condition As it is a closed aspherical manifold. Three appendices treat smooth manifolds with Ric≥−(n−1) and small local rewinding Reifenberg error: a uniform short-time Ricci flow with ∣Rm∣≤α/t, also for complete non-compact data, where it is unique among complete flows with curvature at most A/t; a second construction with affine nilmanifold bundles; and, conditional on Nifa's construction, examples showing that rewinding volume control alone does not give continuous Gromov–Hausdorff approximations with small error.
For 1≤r≤n−1 we study shrinking self-similar ends of the r-mean curvature flow, Sr=c⟨X,N⟩ with c<0, that are asymptotic to a cone. For every rotational cone of positive slope we construct a smooth embedded rotational end and prove that its profile is the only positive solution of the profile equation with the prescribed slope at infinity. Its angular defect xu′−u is strictly negative, which yields r-admissibility, and the profile has a complete asymptotic expansion for u(x)/x in powers of x−(r+1), valid after arbitrary differentiation. The profiles depend real analytically on the slope and, on sufficiently distant exterior regions, foliate the image of the corresponding family. Our main result removes the symmetry assumption: two ends that converge smoothly, with multiplicity one, to the same circular cone coincide outside a compact set. The proof transforms the equation for their difference into an almost-eigenfunction inequality for a drift Laplacian on an auxiliary conical metric and applies Bernstein's asymptotic analysis on weakly conical ends. The argument extends to strictly r-admissible cones whose links have constant principal curvatures.
We give direct proofs of rigidity results for gradient Ricci solitons, compact quasi-Einsteinmanifolds with boundary, and critical spaces with cyclic parallel Ricci tensor. For solitons and quasi-Einstein manifolds, successive traces of first-order pointwise identities yield quadratic equations for the Ricci tensor and its modification. These equations imply radial flatness and radial Q-flatness, respectively, and the corresponding global rigidity theorems apply. For critical spaces, comparison of two expressions for the Laplacian of the Hessian gives a pointwise tensor identity whose scalar contraction yields a weighted divergence formula. Integration then gives the vacuum static, CPE, and Miao–Tam conclusions. The same comparison also proves Ricci parallelism pointwise for solitons and quasi-Einstein manifolds.
We study a positive radial graph evolving by V=Hα+b, with α>0 and b<0, in the unit cylinder and with ur(1,t)=u(1,t). We separate finite-time continuation estimates from the time-uniform interior estimates needed for convergence of normalized translates. On existing classical intervals we prove height and gradient bounds and an explicit conversion of velocity bounds into estimates for H, ur/r, and urr. We derive the correct boundary defect for comparisons with finite-slope translators. Under independent interior velocity bounds and two-sided slope trapping, we prove compactness and identify every translated limit with the cup translator. We identify the radial zero-number comparison still required to establish that trapping. Stationary caps and power-law Robin laws are included.
We study the graphical forced mean curvature flow in a planar strip subject to Robin boundary conditions. The normal velocity is prescribed by V=H+b, where b>0 is constant and H denotes the curvature of the graph. We consider positive even solutions and reduce the problem to the half interval. The main results describe the degeneration produced by the Robin condition: the height, the instantaneous velocity, and the spatial gradient diverge, while the normalized slope ux/u converges to one away from the symmetry axis. The normalized velocity ut/u converges to the forcing parameter b. The curvature converges to zero in the interior in an integral sense, whereas its horizontal curvature measure concentrates at the symmetry axis.
In this paper, we study strong uniqueness for smooth instantaneously complete Chern-Ricci flows on noncompact complex manifolds. Under suitable reference metric and positivity assumptions, we establish strong uniqueness for initial Hermitian metrics which are Kähler outside a compact set. The initial metric may be incomplete, and no curvature, metric comparison, or growth bounds are imposed on the evolving solutions. In particular, we obtain strong uniqueness from complete initial metrics in this class with bounded Chern-Ricci curvature. We also prove stationarity of flows from the Euclidean metric on Cn and uniqueness of the instantaneously complete flow from the Euclidean metric on the complex unit ball for all positive time. Finally, on complex surfaces, we show that a Ricci flow remaining Hermitian for a fixed complex structure is Kähler at all times if it is Kähler at one time, and derive a corresponding strong uniqueness result for Ricci flows in this class.
We study an area-preserving curvature flow for planar open curves whose end points lie on skew lines and meet the lines at general contact angles. In previous studies of moving boundary problems for higher-order geometric gradient flows, the right-angle condition has often been imposed to ensure that the evolving curves naturally satisfy the boundary conditions. However, under general contact-angle conditions, the evolution must be described by a free boundary problem. Under suitable assumptions on the contact angles θ±, the angle θ between the skew lines, and the initial data γ0, we prove global-in-time existence and uniqueness up to reparametrization. We further prove that, after choosing a constant-speed parametrization at each time, the solution converges exponentially to a circular arc with the same signed area as the initial curve. Our analysis is based on a formulation of the evolution as a free boundary problem together with the derivation of uniform a priori estimates.
We prove a uniform scalar curvature bound, depending only on the dimension, for Kähler–Ricci shrinkers. We also prove that every noncompact Kähler–Ricci shrinker has a unique tangent cone at infinity, naturally homeomorphic to the base of its polarized Fano fibration. For shrinkers with maximal volume growth, this cone is isometric to the metric completion of the regular part equipped with the intrinsic distance induced by the limiting Kähler metric.
For noncompact smooth Kähler-Ricci shrinkers, we prove a Matsushima theorem identifying the centralizer of the soliton field with the complexification of its Killing centralizer, uniqueness up to biholomorphism on a fixed complex manifold, and K-polystability of the associated polarized Fano fibration.
We consider the problem of uniqueness of Ricci flows, starting from singular initial data. Even when the initial data is smooth and smoothly obtained, in the complete noncompact case uniqueness is not known in full generality. When starting from nonsmooth initial data, very little is known, even in the compact case. We obtain a uniqueness result for Ricci flows with scaling-invariant curvature bounds, a suitable noncollapsing assumption, and sectional curvature lower bounds, coming out of (possibly singular) Reifenberg spaces. As a consequence of our result, and existence results obtained by Simon–Topping and Lai, there is a canonical way to define a smooth structure on any Reifenberg uniformly volume-noncollapsed PIC2 limit space. Further, we obtain a diffeomorphic version of Perelman's stability theorem for these limit spaces.