In briefCurvature and Ricci flow for graphs, networks and triangulated surfaces. It runs from Chow–Luo's combinatorial flow on circle packings to Ollivier's transport-based curvature, now used in computer graphics and machine learning.
Several discrete versions of Ricci curvature and Ricci flow exist, each capturing a different aspect of the smooth theory.
Combinatorial Ricci flow. Chow and Luo (2003) evolved the radii of a circle packing on a triangulated surface by a discrete analogue of Ricci flow. They proved it converges to Thurston's circle-packing metrics, giving a flow proof of the Andreev–Koebe–Thurston theorem. Discrete conformal geometry followed (Gu, Luo, Sun, Wu and others): a discrete uniformization theorem, and discrete surface Ricci flow for computing conformal maps.
Ollivier curvature. For a graph or Markov chain, compare how far apart the random-walk distributions mx,my of two neighbours are, measured with the Wasserstein distance W1, relative to the distance between the points. That is the formula above. Positive curvature means neighbourhoods overlap, just as balls do on a sphere. Lin, Lu and Yau gave a limiting version for graphs. Forman's curvature, from Bochner-type formulas, is a cheaper alternative.
Graph Ricci flow. Iteratively reweight the edges of a graph by curvature. It has been used for community detection in networks (Ni, Lin, Luo and Gao).
Why it matters
The discrete theory is where Ricci flow ideas meet applications: surface parameterisation in computer graphics and medical imaging, network analysis, and, since 2022, graph neural networks. There, negatively curved "bottleneck" edges were shown to cause over-squashing of information (Topping et al.). For readers from computer science, this is often the first place they meet Ricci curvature.
Where it stands
It is an active applied field, with rigorous results on convergence of discrete flows, curvature bounds for graphs, and discrete-to-continuum limits. A caution: discrete flows share names and heuristics with Hamilton's flow, but the theorems are different, and results do not transfer automatically in either direction. On this site, discrete papers are tagged but kept distinct from the core topics.
If you are new to this
Foundational papers
The papers the rest of the topic builds on, in reading order. Titles open the paper.
Numerical curve shortening and mean curvature flow, level sets and phase fields, discrete Ricci flow on surfaces and in conformal mapping, rotationally symmetric neckpinches, and what computation has taught about singularities.
We study the combinatorial Calabi flow associated with vertex scalings on infinitely triangulated surfaces with piecewise Euclidean and piecewise hyperbolic metrics. Under the assumptions of uniformly bounded vertex degree and an ε-uniformly nondegenerate initial metric, we establish short-time existence of smooth solutions and prove uniqueness among solutions that are continuous in the L∞ norm.
We give local combinatorial criteria for realizing prescribed ideal triangulations by nondegenerate hyperbolic truncated tetrahedra. A local bichromatic criterion allows valence-7 edges when tetrahedra meeting low-valence edges use at most two quotient-edge classes. Using the extended combinatorial Ricci flow, we obtain parameter-dependent criteria for triangulations of minimum valence 6. Symmetric and pair-min angle estimates yield explicit valence conditions, including mixed conditions on entire edge stars. The proofs use analytic angle inequalities and rigorous interval evaluations. Explicit face pairings realize the criteria and distinguish their scope, while cyclic constructions and finite covers give infinite families. Each criterion yields a unique zero-curvature hyper-ideal metric and exponential convergence from any positive initial length vector.
We study the inverse-weight Lin–Lu–YauRicci flow on finite trees, and prove the convergence of the curvature on every edge via its diffusion equation. Moreover, the limiting curvature is the unique minimum-norm point of a polyhedron determined by the tree. We characterize possible limits of the normalized edge weights, give criteria for their convergence, and show that different positive initial metrics have equivalent omega-limit sets.
We present a numerical method that constructs geometrically defined coordinates on black-hole horizons, from which the multipole moments are computed without assuming axisymmetry. This method, which we denote the conformal-mapping method (CMM), provides a numerical realization of the conformal construction proposed by Ashtekar et al. in 2022, combining discrete Ricci flow, spectral embedding onto the unit sphere, and Möbius gauge fixing by the vanishing-area-dipole condition. We first test the CMM against analytic Kerr benchmarks, and then apply it to an equal-mass, non-spinning binary black-hole merger. We also compare it with an approximate-symmetry-based method. The CMM allows the multipole moments to be expressed in a fixed reference frame, whereas the symmetry-adapted frame can reorient abruptly when the preferred approximate axis changes. In a frame aligned with the orbital angular momentum, the amplitude of the quadrupole mode grows during inspiral and decays after merger, displaying a qualitative ringdown behavior. These results show that the CMM is a useful tool for studying horizon geometry in dynamical situations where no stable symmetry axis is available.
In this note, we prove that, on weighted graphs, the Lin–Lu–Yau curvature coincides with the p-Ollivier curvature up to scaling whenever the idleness parameter p≥1/2. Moreover, the threshold 1/2 is sharp. This extends an earlier result of Bourne et al. (Ollivier–Ricci idleness functions of graphs, SIAM J. Discrete Math., 32 (2018), no. 2, 1408-1424), where combinatorial graphs were considered. This observation yields a simple proof for the global existence and uniqueness of solutions of the Lin–Lu–Yau curvature flow in Bai et al. (Ollivier Ricci-flow on weighted graphs, Amer. J. Math. 146 (2024), 1723-1747).
We study the combinatorial Yamabe flow on infinitely triangulated surfaces with piecewise hyperbolic metrics. Under the assumptions of uniformly bounded vertex degree and an ε-uniformly nondegenerate initial metric, we establish the short-time existence and uniqueness of smooth solutions to the combinatorial Yamabe flow. To address the potential degeneration of triangles along the evolution, we introduce an extended flow with generalized curvature, and establish the global existence of solutions to the extended flow.Furthermore, under an integrability condition, we establish the uniqueness of solutions to this extended flow, which follows from the stability property of the solutions. These results provide a local well-posedness theory for the hyperbolic combinatorial Yamabe flow on infinitely triangulated surfaces.
In this paper, we study three-dimensional combinatorial Yamabe flows on locally finite infinite triangulations in Euclidean and hyperbolic background geometries. Under suitable non-degeneracy and bounded-degree assumptions, we establish the short-time existence and uniqueness of the original flows. We further introduce the extended flows by using the continuous extension of solid angles, and prove long-time existence for both extended flows under suitable initial assumptions.
Nilpotent Lie groups with left-invariant metrics provide nontrivial examples of Ricci solitons. Some typical examples are given by the class of two-step nilpotent Lie algebras obtained from simple directed graphs and the class of nilpotent Lie algebras obtained from finite acyclic quivers. In this paper, we generalize the construction of nilpotent Lie algebras that are algebraic Ricci solitons obtained from finite acyclic quivers. We use some special ordered sets to construct nilpotent Lie algebras, which can also be obtained from some special quivers with relations. A transitively and antisymmetrically ordered set (or TAOS, for short) is a set together with a binary relation that is transitive and antisymmetric. Utilizing the concept of incidence algebras of TAOSs, we construct nilpotent Lie algebras. We modify the method introduced by Mizoguchi and Tamaru and use it to show that the nilpotent Lie algebras with arbitrarily high degrees of nilpotency obtained from some special finite transitively and antisymmetrically ordered sets, called array TAOSs, are algebraic Ricci solitons. We also give some generalizations of this result, which yield more nilpotent Lie algebras that are algebraic Ricci solitons. Moreover, the corresponding simply-connected nilpotent Lie groups admit left-invariant Ricci solitons.
In this paper, we consider the Ricci flow with prescribed curvature on infinite graphs, which reads as \beginequation* \fracddtω(t)=-(κ(t)-κ^*)ω(t), t>0, \endequation* where ω is the edge weight, κ and κ∗ are Lin-Lu-Yau Ricci curvature and the prescribed curvature on the set of edges, respectively. First, we establish the existence and uniqueness of the solution to the Ricci flow. Furthermore, we prove the convergence of the Ricci flow for graphs with girth at least 6 under two different conditions. Our convergence result aligns with the conclusion of Rodin and Sullivan (J Differ Geom, 26(2) 1987) that a circle packing in the plane with the hexagonal pattern is the regular hexagonal packing.
In this paper, we investigate the prescribed curvature problem associated with a special Lin-Lu-Yau curvature on finite graphs of girth at least 6. We define the corresponding Calabi flow for this curvature type, and establish an equivalent characterization of the problem, namely, the solution to the Calabi flow exists globally in time and converges if and only if there exists a weight function that realizes the prescribed curvature. In particular, for constant curvature weights, we prove that the solution to the Calabi flow exists globally in time and converges under certain topological conditions.
In this paper, we consider the Ricci flow with prescribed curvature on the finite graphG=(V,E). For any e in E, dtdω(t,e)=−(κ(t,e)−κ∗(e))ω(t,e),t>0, where ω is the weight function, κ is Lin-Lu-Yau Ricci curvature, and κ∗ is the prescribed curvature. By imposing invariance of the graph distance with respect to time t, the Ricci flow introduced above characterizes the weight evolution governed by the Lin-Lu-Yau curvature. We first establish the existence and uniqueness of the solution to this equation on general graphs. Furthermore, for graphs with girth of at least 6, we prove that the Ricci flow converges exponentially to weights of κ∗ if and only if κ∗ is attainable (namely, there exist weights realizing κ∗). In particular, we prove that the weights for constant curvature exist if and only if ∅=Ω⊊Vmax∣Ω∣∣E(Ω)∣<∣V∣∣E∣, where E(Ω) denotes the set of edges within the induced subgraph of Ω, and ∣A∣ is the cardinality of the set A. Viewing edge weights as metrics on surface tilings with girth of at least 5 or the duals of triangulations with vertex degrees exceeding 5, we demonstrate that our constant Lin-Lu-Yau curvature flow serves as an analog to the 2D combinatorial Ricci flow for piecewise constant curvature metrics, thereby providing an affirmative answer to Question 2 posed by Chow and Luo (J Differ Geom, 63(1) 2002).
Let S be an oriented closed surface with a cellular decomposition D and a weight Φ∈(0,π). It is crucial to determine when S supports an ideal D-type circle pattern P with the exterior intersection angles given by Φ. Rivin, Bobenko-Springborn and Ge-Hua-Zhou provided perfect solutions and gave wonderful criteria for the existence and uniqueness of ideal circle patterns. However, all criteria established by Rivin, Bobenko-Springborn and Ge-Hua-Zhou are extremely difficult to verify for the given cellular decomposition D and the weight Φ. In this paper, we introduce the character L(D,Φ) depends only on the data of the weighted cellular decomposition (D,Φ) on S, and give some quite simple criteria for the existence of ideal circle patterns realizing (D,Φ). It seems that our character-type criteria are the first conditions totally different from criteria of Rivin, Bobenko-Springborn and Ge-Hua-Zhou, and provide more easily verifiable criteria. Our new character-type theorems may be of some independent interest. As an application, we give a new descriptions of the curvature image set K(R>0N). To approach our results, we shall use the combinatorial Ricci flows with ideal circle patterns introduced by Ge-Hua-Zhou as a fundamental tool. The main difficulty in the proof of our results is to establish the compactness of the solution to the flows. To circumvent the difficulty, we borrow the techniques developed by Ge and his collaborators.
In this paper, we study a combinatorial Ricci flow on closed pseudo 3-manifolds (M,T). We prove that if every edge in the triangulation T has valence at least 9, then the combinatorial Ricci flowconverges exponentially fast to the unique zero-curvature hyper-ideal metric. As a consequence, for any compact 3-manifold N with boundary admitting an ideal triangulation TN whose edges all have valence at least 9, there exists a unique complete hyperbolic metric with totally geodesic boundary on N such that TN is isotopic to a geometric decomposition of N. This provides a partial solution to the conjecture of Costantino, Frigerio, Martelli and Petronio, and hence an affirmative answer to Thurston's geometric ideal triangulation conjecture for such manifolds. Moreover, we obtain explicit upper and lower bounds for the resulting hyperbolic metric.