Geometry & analysis

Weak & singular flows

In briefRunning a flow when the data isn't smooth or singularities form: Ricci flows from rough initial data, through singularities and on metric measure spaces, and the Brakke and level-set flows that do the same for mean curvature flow.

g0∈C0  ⟹  ∃ g(t), t∈(0,T],  g(t)→g0 uniformly as t↘0g_0 \in C^0 \;\Longrightarrow\; \exists\, g(t),\ t\in(0,T],\ \ g(t) \to g_0 \text{ uniformly as } t \searrow 0
135papers
7in the last 30 days
11key references
1guidebook chapters

The ideas that matter here

Key concepts

Each one in a few lines, with the equation that carries it and the stage of the Guidebook where it is learned.

Singular Ricci flowsadvanced

Surgery works, but it depends on arbitrary parameters: how thin a neck must be before you cut. Kleiner and Lott removed the choice. A singular Ricci flow is a 4-dimensional spacetime M\mathcal{M} with a time function, a time vector field and a metric on the time slices, satisfying the canonical neighborhood assumption below any scale.

For every compact 3-manifold, such a flow exists and continues through its singularities with no parameters at all. Bamler–Kleiner then proved it is unique and depends continuously on the initial metric: Ricci flow through singularities is a canonical, deterministic process.

Where the concept cards came from: they were drafted by an AI at the site owner's request. The owner, who is still learning this material, chose which concepts to include but cannot vouch for every detail, so treat them as a well-drawn map and check the cited papers. Corrections are welcome: see how this site works.

Guide

In depth

What it is

Three kinds of "weak" Ricci flow have emerged, and mean curvature flow has its own.

  • Rough initial data. Simon (2002) started Ricci flow from continuous metrics, using the Ricci–DeTurck flow to smooth them instantly. Koch and Lamm treated metrics that are only L∞L^\infty-close to Euclidean. In dimension three, Simon and Topping (and independently Hochard) started flows from metrics with Ricci curvature bounded below and used them to show that non-collapsed 3D Ricci limit spaces are topological manifolds. On surfaces, Topping's instantaneously complete flows allow almost any initial metric.
  • Flows through singularities. Kleiner and Lott's singular Ricci flows are space-times that are smooth except at singular points, obtained as the limit of Perelman's surgery with scale going to zero. Bamler and Kleiner proved they are unique. In higher dimensions, Bamler's metric flows are the limits of smooth flows under his compactness theory, a candidate framework for weak flows in general.
  • Synthetic flows. Sturm defined super Ricci flows of metric measure spaces using optimal transport, parallel to the synthetic lower Ricci bounds of Lott–Villani and Sturm. Haslhofer and Naber characterised smooth Ricci flows by estimates on path space.
  • Weak mean curvature flow. The extrinsic theory got there first. Brakke (1978) defined flows of varifolds by an inequality for how their weighted area changes in time. Evans and Spruck, and independently Chen, Giga and Goto, defined the level-set flow: the surface is a level set of a function solving a degenerate parabolic equation in the viscosity sense, which exists and is unique for all time but can fatten. Ilmanen connected the two, and phase-field approximations give a third route (see phase fields and multiphase flows). Minimizing movements, a time-discrete variational scheme, are used for anisotropic and multiphase flows.

Why it matters

Singularities are unavoidable, and many natural metrics (limits, gluings, spaces with cone points) are not smooth. Weak formulations let Ricci flow act as a smoothing tool on singular spaces, and make it continuous and canonical through singularities, which is what the diffeomorphism-group results require. They also connect Ricci flow to optimal transport and non-smooth geometry. For mean curvature flow the weak theories are what made the classification of generic singularities possible.

Where it stands

In dimension three the singular theory is complete. In higher dimensions a well-posed notion of weak Ricci flow through general singularities is the central open problem. Bamler's metric flows are the leading candidate, but uniqueness and continuation remain open. Rough-data existence and the regularity of flows from singular spaces (cones, orbifolds, RCD spaces) are active; see also limit spaces and RCD.

If you are new to this

Foundational papers

The papers the rest of the topic builds on, in reading order. Titles open the paper.

  1. 2002
    Deformation of Riemannian metrics in the direction of their Ricci curvature Miles Simon · Communications in Analysis and Geometry, vol. 10 Simon: Ricci flow from metrics. DOI 10.4310/CAG.2002.v10.n5.a7
  2. 2009
    Geometric flows with rough initial data Herbert Koch, Tobias Lamm · arXiv:0902.1488 Koch–Lamm: geometric flows with rough initial data. PDFarXiv:0902.1488
  3. 2017
    Local mollification of Riemannian metrics using Ricci flow, and Ricci limit spaces Miles Simon, Peter M. Topping · Geom. Topol. 25 (2021) 913-948 Simon–Topping: local mollification by Ricci flow, and 3D Ricci limit spaces. PDFarXiv:1706.09490Journal version
  4. 2014
    Singular Ricci flows I Bruce Kleiner, John Lott · arXiv:1408.2271 Kleiner–Lott: singular Ricci flows. View paper Connections
  5. 2017
    Uniqueness and stability of Ricci flow through singularities Richard H. Bamler, Bruce Kleiner · arXiv:1709.04122 Bamler–Kleiner: uniqueness and stability of singular flows. View paper Connections
  6. 2016
    Super-Ricci Flows for Metric Measure Spaces Karl-Theodor Sturm · arXiv:1603.02193 Sturm: super-Ricci flows for metric measure spaces. PDFarXiv:1603.02193
  7. 2020
    Compactness theory of the space of Super Ricci flows Richard H Bamler · arXiv:2008.09298 Bamler: compactness theory for super Ricci flows and metric flows. View paper ConnectionsJournal version
  8. 2015
    The Motion of a Surface by Its Mean Curvature. (MN-20) Kenneth A. Brakke · Princeton University Press Brakke: *The Motion of a Surface by Its Mean Curvature* (first published 1978), weak flows of varifolds. DOI 10.1515/9781400867431
  9. 1991
    Motion of level sets by mean curvature. I L. C. Evans, J. Spruck · Journal of Differential Geometry, vol. 33 Evans–Spruck: motion of level sets by mean curvature. DOI 10.4310/jdg/1214446559
  10. 1991
    Uniqueness and existence of viscosity solutions of generalized mean curvature flow equations Yun Gang Chen, Yoshikazu Giga, Shun'ichi Goto · Journal of Differential Geometry, vol. 33 Chen–Giga–Goto: viscosity solutions of level-set curvature flows. DOI 10.4310/jdg/1214446564

Where to start reading

Surveys & books

Longer, gentler routes in, and the references specialists keep on their desks.

  1. 2021
    Recent developments in Ricci flows Richard H Bamler · arXiv:2102.12615 Bamler's survey, including the metric-flow framework. View paper Connections

Learn it step by step

In the guidebook

Chapters of the Guidebook that build weak & singular flows from the ground up, with proofs, figures and exercises.

  1. 12C.9
    After PerelmanBook 12C · Extinction and the Proof

    Singular flows, the Smale conjecture, and Bamler’s theory.

If you follow the research

Latest papers · 135 papers

The newest 20, updated every weekday from arXiv. Follow this topic with its own RSS feed, or see who writes most on it.

math.DGarXiv:2611.06814

Uniqueness of Ricci flows from singular initial data

Laura Flower, Man-Chun Lee, Felix Schulze

We establish uniqueness of Ricci flows with non-negative sectional curvatures and scaling invariant curvature bounds, assuming that the induced distance functions converge to the same initial distance function up to isometry. In the compact case, restricting the size of the initial singular set, we also establish uniqueness under suitable weaker conditions.

View paper Connections
math.DGWider flowsarXiv:2610.38929

Mean-convex horizontal mean curvature flow in the Heisenberg group

Gaia Bombardieri, Mattia Fogagnolo, Valentina Franceschi

We study the arrival time equation of the mean-convex horizontal mean curvature flow in the Heisenberg group. We prove existence of viscosity solutions when the initial set is horizontally mean-convex and either non-characteristic, or axisymmetric and with horizontal mean curvature extending continuously across the characteristic set. A key ingredient is an approximation scheme by sets with prescribed Riemannian mean curvature, which preserves the mean-curvature bounds up to an arbitrarily small error. We further show that, when the evolving level sets form a generalized -foliation, the horizontal mean curvature blows up around characteristic points. This provides an obstruction to self-similar evolution in the axisymmetric class considered above and, in particular, shows that the Pansu sphere cannot evolve self-similarly.

View paper Connections
math.APWider flowsarXiv:2610.21545

Generic Mean Curvature Flow With Rough Weights

Fabius Krämer, Tim Laux, Keisuke Takasao

We prove the generic existence of mean curvature flows in spaces with rough weights. Our weak solutions are both unit-density Brakke flows and distributional solutions. Such a generic statement is optimal in the sense that we consider weights that are too rough to have well-defined traces on every hypersurface.

View paper Connections
math.DGWider flowsarXiv:2610.20453

Allen–Cahn and mean curvature flows from Clifford hypersurfaces to equators

Jingwen Chen

In this short note, using OpenAI's resolution of the Solomon–Yau conjecture, we extend our joint work with Pedro Gaspar to all dimensions . We construct eternal Allen–Cahn flows on connecting approximations of any prescribed least-area Clifford hypersurface and equatorial sphere. We also construct infinitely many eternal integral Brakke flows from least-area Clifford hypersurfaces to equatorial spheres.

View paper Connections
math.DGWider flowsv2arXiv:2610.20054

A semi-discrete scheme for horizontal mean curvature flow in the Heisenberg group

A. Cesaroni, M. Novaga, P. Pozzi

The horizontal mean curvature flow is a geometric evolution associated with the horizontal perimeter in sub-Riemannian spaces. In this paper, we introduce a minimizing movement scheme for this flow in the first Heisenberg group , and prove the existence of a flat flow which is locally -Hölder continuous in time, with respect to the -distance. The construction applies to arbitrary bounded sets of finite horizontal perimeter and does not require smoothness or symmetry of the initial datum.

View paper Connections
math.DGWider flowsv2arXiv:2610.18761

Modified support measures and Alexandrov-Fenchel type inequalities for nonsmooth h-convex bodies in hyperbolic space

Xinxiu Zhang

We establish the Alexandrov-Fenchel inequality and its modified version for arbitrary, possibly nonsmooth, horospherically convex bodies in hyperbolic space , and prove that equality in each inequality holds if and only if the h-convex body is a geodesic ball. A key ingredient is a rigidity theorem characterizing geodesic balls via proportionality between modified support measures of adjacent orders. Its proof combines the approximation of the outer parallel hypersurfaces by smooth strictly h-convex hypersurfaces with the estimates for the total variation norm of the signed measure associated with the proportionality relation along the shifted curvature flows independent of initial curvature bounds. For , we construct weak flows preserving the -th modified quermassintegral with arbitrary h-convex initial bodies as Hausdorff limits of the smooth flows. The rigidity theorem above characterizes the limit shape of the flow and gives a positive lower bound on the rate of decrease of for a short time whenever the initial h-convex body is not a geodesic ball, which characterizes the equality cases in the modified Alexandrov-Fenchel inequality. For the Alexandrov-Fenchel inequality, we establish the Hausdorff stability independent of curvature bounds described by the Alexandrov-Fenchel deficits for h-convex bodies, which characterizes the equality cases in the Alexandrov-Fenchel inequality.

View paper Connections
math.DGv2arXiv:2610.17229

The Singular Fibration of Collapsing RCD Spaces with Reifenberg Local Covers

Shaosai Huang

Let compact spaces converge in the measured Gromov–Hausdorff sense, and suppose that they have -Reifenberg local covers for one fixed , with and small. We prove that, along a subsequence, the spaces are singular fibrations over the limit: their canonical frame spaces converge to a topological manifold with a locally linear action of whose quotient is the limit; for large indices the frame spaces fibre over this manifold, by maps that commute with , with fibres homeomorphic to nilmanifolds; and the induced maps to the limit are, near every point, quotients of products by the isotropy group, with fibres homeomorphic to infranilmanifolds. As applications, we extend a fibration theorem of Honda and Zhang to non-smooth RCD spaces whose local covers have injectivity radius bounded below, and we show that for aspherical spaces the isotropy groups are finite, the fibre groups inject into the fundamental groups, and the limit is the quotient of a contractible manifold by a proper cocompact action; under Rong's condition it is a closed aspherical manifold. Three appendices treat smooth manifolds with and small local rewinding Reifenberg error: a uniform short-time Ricci flow with , also for complete non-compact data, where it is unique among complete flows with curvature at most ; a second construction with affine nilmanifold bundles; and, conditional on Nifa's construction, examples showing that rewinding volume control alone does not give continuous Gromov–Hausdorff approximations with small error.

View paper Connections
math.DGWider flowsarXiv:2610.10461

Sharp dynamical isoperimetric principle for mean curvature flow

Beomjun Choi, Wenkui Du, Seung Chul Park, Junseo Youn

In this paper, we establish a sharp dynamical isoperimetric principle for weak mean curvature flow. We prove that, among weak mean curvature flows with fixed area of initial smooth closed hypersurfaces, the standard smoothly shrinking spherical mean curvature flow uniquely maximizes the extinction time. More precisely, for the level set flow starting from the boundary of a smooth bounded domain , as well as for the integral Brakke flow with initial Radon measure , we establish the corresponding optimal extinction time estimates \beginequation* T_{\rm ext}(Ω),\, T^B_{\rm ext}(Ω) \leq \frac12n \left(\fracP( Ω){|{\mathbbS^n}|}\right)^{\frac2n}, \endequation* where is the perimeter of representing the area of , and the equality holds if and only if is a round ball and the flow is the standard multiplicity-one smoothly self-shrinking round sphere. In particular, we obtain the sharp -estimates for the arrival time function of a smooth bounded mean convex domain. In addition, we also establish the sharp isoperimetric inequality for the parabolic measure of the space-time track filling of outward minimizing level set flow starting from the boundary of a smooth bounded domain : \beginequation* \mathcal H_par^n+2(X) \leq \fracπ {2n(n+2)^2|{\mathbbS^n}|^{{\frac2n}}} P(Ω)^{\fracn+2n}, \endequation* where the equality holds if and only if is a round ball and the flow is standard smoothly shrinking round sphere.

View paper Connections
math.CVarXiv:2610.06473

Complex Monge-Ampère equations on Hermitian Manifolds: From bounded to smooth solutions

Papa Badiane, Chinh H. Lu, Ahmed Zeriahi

We study regularity of bounded weak solutions to complex Monge-Ampère equations on compact Hermitian manifolds with right-hand side possibly decreasing in the unknown. Our proof relies on the domination principle and a priori estimates, partially motivated by the Monge-Ampère eigenvalue problem. Our main result roughly says that any bounded solution is smooth in the regular locus of the data. When the right-hand side is strictly positive and smooth, we recover known results by Nie, Ko lodziej-Nguyen for the Hermitian case and Székelyhidi-Tosatti for the Kähler case, which rely on the regularizing property of the Kähler-Ricci flow.

View paper Connections
math.DGarXiv:2610.03129

On the uniqueness of Ricci flows from certain Alexandrov spaces

Laura Flower

We consider the problem of uniqueness of Ricci flows, starting from singular initial data. Even when the initial data is smooth and smoothly obtained, in the complete noncompact case uniqueness is not known in full generality. When starting from nonsmooth initial data, very little is known, even in the compact case. We obtain a uniqueness result for Ricci flows with scaling-invariant curvature bounds, a suitable noncollapsing assumption, and sectional curvature lower bounds, coming out of (possibly singular) Reifenberg spaces. As a consequence of our result, and existence results obtained by Simon–Topping and Lai, there is a canonical way to define a smooth structure on any Reifenberg uniformly volume-noncollapsed PIC2 limit space. Further, we obtain a diffeomorphic version of Perelman's stability theorem for these limit spaces.

View paper Connections
math.APWider flowsarXiv:2610.00732

Global weak varifold solutions to Navier-Stokes/Mean Curvature Flow system

Andrea Poiatti

The Navier-Stokes/Mean Curvature Flow system describes a two-phase flow of incompressible, viscous and immiscible fluids separated by a sharp interface, whose evolution is governed by a convective mean curvature flow equation, coupled to a two-phase Navier-Stokes equation accounting for surface tension. Among others, this model describes the dynamics of dry foams and it also arises as a sharp interface limit of Navier-Stokes/Allen-Cahn systems with non-vanishing mobility. Despite this wide range of applications, global-in-time existence of any kind of weak solutions remains a challenging open problem. In this work, we introduce a novel notion of varifold weak solution in two and three ambient dimensions, based on a sharp energy dissipation principle à la De Giorgi, and we show for the first time the unconditional global-in-time existence of such a weak solution. We also show, by means of a relative entropy approach, that any classical solution to the Navier-Stokes/Mean Curvature Flow system is unique in the class of our new weak varifold solutions.

View paper Connections
math.DGWider flowsarXiv:2609.01026

Quantitative avoidance for free boundary flows and applications

Yueheng Bao, Robert Haslhofer

In this article, we introduce a new distance function between hypersurfaces with free boundary. We show that our new quantity, which we call twisted Fermi distance, is monotone under mean curvature flow with free boundary. This overcomes the stumbling block that monotonicity of the usual distance function can fail for non-convex domains, and has several applications. Most importantly, we generalize the avoidance principle for free boundary Brakke flows, recently established by the first author for convex domains, to arbitrary domains. Using this, we then show that all results from our recent joint work, including the mean-convex neighborhood theorem and the uniqueness theorem for free boundary flows through cylindrical singularities, can be generalized to arbitrary domains without any convexity assumptions as well.

View paper Connections
math.APWider flowsv2arXiv:2608.26842

Convergence of a vector-valued Allen-Cahn system to Brakke's multiphase mean curvature flow

Tim Laux, Keisuke Takasao

Since Ilmanen's pioneering work [J. Differential Geom. 38, 417-461, (1993)] it has been a major open problem to understand the sharp-interface limit of systems of coupled Allen-Cahn equations. We prove - for the first time - a global, unconditional convergence result for such a coupled system and show that the limit is a multiphase mean curvature flow in the sense of Brakke.

View paper Connections
math.DGarXiv:2608.19152

Kähler-Ricci Tangent Flows in the Analytic Minimal Model Program

Longteng Chen, Max Hallgren, Lucas Lavoyer

We describe certain finite-time singularities of the Kähler-Ricci flow arising in the analytic minimal model program. Assuming that convergence to an asymptotically conical Kähler-Ricci shrinker is realized by holomorphic maps, we prove that, in a fixed holomorphic gauge, the nearby flow is modeled on the shrinker at the level of Kähler potentials. Consequently, every noncollapsed Kähler-Ricci flow through singularities in complex dimension two is modeled on a shrinker-cone-expander transition, confirming a strong form of Song's conjectural picture. We also show analogous results in higher dimensions under the Calabi ansatz, and improve known results in the compact shrinker case. These give the first compact Ricci flows through conical singularities whose small-scale behavior is fully described.

View paper Connections
math.APWider flowsarXiv:2608.05760

A note on generalized BV mean curvature flow with a critical forcing term

Kiichi Tashiro

In this note, we show that a weak mean curvature flow with critical forcing term obtained by Liu–Tonegawa (2024) satisfies the BV-type area change formula, that is, their flow is not only a Brakke flow but also a generalized BV flow, which is proposed by Stuvard–Tonegawa (2024). To establish this result, we identify minimal conditions under which a Brakke flow satisfies the area-change formula. As an application of our main theorem, we derive a lower bound for the extinction time of generalized BV flows with a critical forcing term. We also outline the proof of a compactness theorem for generalized BV flows.

View paper Connections
math.APWider flowsarXiv:2608.00293

A Phase-Field Method for Curvature Flow of Networks with Triple Junction Drag

Yuchuan Yang, Selim Esedoglu

We develop a new phase-field (diffuse interface) approximation of multiphase curvature motion with triple junction drag - an important sharp interface model for the evolution of microstructure in polycrystalline materials during heat treatment. This sharp interface model arises as gradient flow for the total length of the interfacial network with respect to a certain metric. Accordingly, we derive our diffuse interface approximation - a coupled system of partial differential equations that is a variant of the Allen-Cahn system - from a variational perspective, in the style of minimizing movements: starting from a discrete in time approximation that entails a convex optimization problem to advance from one time step to the next. In the process, we propose a simple integral expression that counts the number of junctions using the order parameter that appears to be new even for the standard multiphase Allen-Cahn system. The convergence of the resulting flow to the desired sharp interface limit is then verified via the method of matched asymptotic expansions. Numerical convergence studies against both known exact solutions as well as highly accurate benchmark solutions obtained via front tracking provide clear further evidence for this convergence. Moreover, the method retains the most desirable feature of diffuse interface methods: Automatic handling of topological changes in the network of interfaces.

View paper Connections
math.DGWider flowsarXiv:2607.10426

Spacelike Brakke flows with boundary in pseudo-Euclidean space

Javier Hervás

We develop a weak formulation of spacelike mean curvature flow in pseudo-Euclidean space. The framework is based on spacelike integer rectifiable varifolds and a pseudo-Euclidean version of first variation. Particular attention is paid to the presence of a fixed spacelike boundary. We introduce a generalized mean curvature vector and a weak spacelike conormal along the boundary. Under natural uniform spacelikeness and curvature assumptions, we prove a closure theorem for spacelike varifolds with boundary. We then define spacelike Brakke flows by means of the corresponding pseudo-Euclidean Brakke inequality, and prove a compactness theorem for sequences of spacelike Brakke flows with fixed boundary. Basic monotonicity properties are established, reflecting the sign structure of the ambient indefinite metric. Finally, we adapt Ilmanen's elliptic regularization procedure to prove existence of spacelike Brakke flows, and the local regularity theorem of White to the pseudo-Euclidean setting. The results provide a varifold setting for studying weak spacelike mean curvature flow beyond singularities.

View paper Connections
math.APWider flowsarXiv:2607.06698

Infinity-harmonic functions and inverse mean curvature flow clusters

Kai Xu

An -harmonic function is a viscosity solution of , or equivalently, an absolute minimizer of . We prove a variety of new structural and regularity results in two dimensions, including: 1. -harmonic functions in domains of are . 2. Critical points are isolated, and at each critical point, the solution has a unique quasiradial blow-up. 3. Entire solutions with polynomial growth have unique quasiradial blow-downs, and are determined by their Fourier modes at infinity. These results are consequences of a new theory relating -harmonic functions to inverse mean curvature flow (IMCF) clusters – which are piecewise weak solutions of IMCF with common obstacle-type boundary conditions on the interfaces (a simple example is an embedded family of cuspidal curves evolving by inverse curvature). This connection arises as the limit of the classical duality between -harmonic and -harmonic functions in , where .

View paper Connections
math.APWider flowsarXiv:2607.03930

De Giorgi varifold solutions to Mean Curvature Flow: a minimizing movements approach

Tim Laux, Andrea Poiatti

We propose an alternative existence proof of global weak solutions to mean curvature flow and volume preserving mean curvature flow. We prove for the first time for a minimizing movements scheme the unconditional convergence towards a varifold solution, here a De Giorgi solution. The argument is purely variational and does not rely on comparison principles. The key novelty is an alternative proxy for the completely degenerate distance that is more robust than the one of Almgren-Taylor-Wang and Luckhaus-Sturzenhecker.

View paper Connections
math.DGWider flowsarXiv:2607.02067

Higher regularity of the inverse anisotropic mean curvature flow

Chaoqun Gao, Yong Wei, Rong Zhou

We prove an anisotropic analogue of the higher regularity theorem of Huisken and Ilmanen for inverse mean curvature flow. For an arbitrary smooth Minkowski norm, we first prove a Huisken–Ilmanen type Harnack estimate for smooth closed strictly star-shaped solutions. We then construct global smooth solutions starting from strictly star-shaped hypersurfaces with bounded nonnegative weak anisotropic mean curvature. Combining this construction with the asymptotic theory for weak inverse anisotropic mean curvature flow, we show that weak solutions starting from bounded smooth initial sets become smooth outside a compact set.

View paper Connections

All 135 papers on Weak & singular flows, by year