Paper · Aug 28, 2019

The Optimal Double Bubble for Density

Jack Hirsch, Kevin Li, Jackson Petty, Christopher Xue

As on arXiv

Abstract

In 1993 Foisy et al. proved that the optimal Euclidean planar double bubble—the least-perimeter way to enclose and separate two given areas—is three circular arcs meeting at 120 degrees. We consider the plane with density , joining the surge of research on manifolds with density after their appearance in Perelman's 2006 proof of the Poincaré Conjecture. Dahlberg et al. proved that the best single bubble in the plane with density is a circle through the origin. We conjecture that the best double bubble is the Euclidean solution with one of the vertices at the origin, for which we have verified equilibrium (first variation or "first derivative" zero). To prove the exterior of the minimizer connected, it would suffice to show that least perimeter is increasing as a function of the prescribed areas. We give the first direct proof of such monotonicity for the Euclidean case. Such arguments were important in the 2002 Annals proof of the double bubble in Euclidean 3-space

Submitted
Aug 28, 2019
Last revised
Nov 19, 2020 (v2)
Subjects
math.MG
Journal
Rose-Hulman Undergraduate Mathematics Journal, 22 (2022), Issue 2, Article 4

Comments: 15 pages, 10 figures

Its neighbourhood

Connected papers

The 8 papers on this site closest to this one, judged by the topics they share, the words and phrases in their titles and abstracts, and their authors. They are not its citations, but a map of the work around it. Papers here go back to 2016, plus the canon.

Connected papers This paper in the centre and the 8 papers closest to it around it, in date order clockwise from the top. The closer a paper sits to the centre, the stronger the connection. This paper Ricci Flow and the Poincare Conjecture (John W. Morgan and Gang Tian, 2006)1Morgan 2006 Hamilton-Perelman's Proof of the Poincaré Conjecture and the Geometrization Conjecture (Huai-Dong Cao and Xi-Ping Zhu, 2006)5Cao 2006 Wave Approximation of Backward Heat Equation with Ricci Flow (Jie Xu, 2020)4Xu 2020 Product structure and regularity theorem for totally nonnegative flag varieties (Huanchen Bao and Xuhua He, 2022)7Bao 2022 On 4-dimensional smooth Poincare conjecture (Selman Akbulut, 2022)2Akbulut 2022 Moving Manifolds and the Poincare Conjecture (David V. Svintradze, 2025)8Svintradze 2025 Equations in Products of Free Groups and 3-Manifold Groups, I (Olga Kharlampovich and Alina Vdovina, 2026)3Kharlampovic 2026 A Lean Formalization of the Hamilton–Perelman Proof of the Three-Dimensional Poincaré Conjecture (Ziyang Qin, Yuan Liao, Ayush Khaitan et al., 2026)6Qin 2026
Closer to the centre: more closely connected. Clockwise from the top: oldest to newest. Ricci flowWider flowsalso connected to each other
  1. Ricci Flow and the Poincare Conjecture

    John W. Morgan and Gang TianThe canon

    Topics Poincaré conjecture · Shared terms “Perelman”

  2. Equations in Products of Free Groups and 3-Manifold Groups, I

    Olga Kharlampovich and Alina Vdovina

    Topics Poincaré conjecture · Shared terms “Perelman proof”, “verified”

  3. Wave Approximation of Backward Heat Equation with Ricci Flow

    Jie Xu

    Topics Poincaré conjecture · Shared terms “Euclidean”, “Perelman”

  4. Hamilton-Perelman's Proof of the Poincaré Conjecture and the Geometrization Conjecture

    Huai-Dong Cao and Xi-Ping ZhuThe canon

    Topics Poincaré conjecture · Shared terms “Perelman proof”

  5. Moving Manifolds and the Poincare Conjecture

    David V. Svintradze

    Topics Poincaré conjecture · Shared terms “equilibrium”

Read around it

Background reading

The guides for the topics of this paper: what each idea is, why it matters, and the papers to read first.

In the guidebook

  1. 7A.12
    The Poincaré Conjecture, PreciselyBook 7A · Topology and the Fundamental Group

    Every word of the statement, and why each hypothesis is needed.

  2. 10A.4
    Homotopy Groups, Degree and the Hurewicz TheoremBook 10A · Three-Manifolds and Geometrization

    Spheres mapped into manifolds: the algebraic topology that finite extinction runs on.

  3. 10A.6
    Necks, Caps and Their TopologyBook 10A · Three-Manifolds and Geometrization

    What an ε-neck is, how necks overlap and chain into tubes, and which manifolds necks and caps can build.