Geometry & analysis

Harmonic maps & DeTurck trick

In briefRicci flow is only weakly parabolic, because it is invariant under diffeomorphisms. The DeTurck trick adds a Lie-derivative term that makes it strictly parabolic, and the diffeomorphisms that undo it solve the harmonic map heat flow, the gradient flow of the Dirichlet energy.

∂tφ=τg,h(φ)=tr⁡g∇dφ\partial_t \varphi = \tau_{g,h}(\varphi) = \operatorname{tr}_g \nabla d\varphi
54papers
1in the last 30 days
8key references

Guide

In depth

What it is

A map φ ⁣:(M,g)→(N,h)\varphi\colon (M,g)\to(N,h) is harmonic if it is a critical point of the Dirichlet energy 12∫M∣dφ∣2\tfrac12\int_M |d\varphi|^2, that is, if its tension field τ(φ)=tr⁡g∇dφ\tau(\varphi) = \operatorname{tr}_g\nabla d\varphi vanishes. The harmonic map heat flow ∂tφ=τ(φ)\partial_t\varphi = \tau(\varphi) is the gradient flow of the energy. Eells and Sampson (1964), in one of the first uses of a geometric heat flow, proved that when NN has non-positive sectional curvature the flow exists for all time and converges to a harmonic map homotopic to the initial one. Without that curvature condition the flow can blow up: Struwe showed that from surfaces it develops at most finitely many singular points, where harmonic spheres bubble off, and Chang, Ding and Ye showed that finite-time blow-up really happens.

Why it matters for Ricci flow

The Ricci flow ∂tg=−2Ric⁡(g)\partial_t g = -2\operatorname{Ric}(g) is not strictly parabolic: pulling a solution back by diffeomorphisms gives another solution, so the symbol of the equation degenerates in the directions of those diffeomorphisms. Hamilton's first proof of short-time existence used the Nash–Moser theorem. DeTurck (1983) found a simpler route. Fix a background metric gˉ\bar g and solve the Ricci–DeTurck flow

∂tg=−2Ric⁡(g)+LWg,Wk=gij(Γijk−Γˉijk),\partial_t g = -2\operatorname{Ric}(g) + \mathcal L_W g,\qquad W^k = g^{ij}\bigl(\Gamma^k_{ij} - \bar\Gamma^k_{ij}\bigr),

which is strictly parabolic. The diffeomorphisms that convert it back into Ricci flow solve a harmonic map heat flow. The same link runs in the other direction in uniqueness proofs, including Chen and Zhu's on complete non-compact manifolds, and the Ricci–DeTurck flow is the standard tool for stability results and for starting the flow from rough metrics.

Harmonic map flow also couples to Ricci flow directly. Müller studied the system of Ricci flow and harmonic map flow, which has a Perelman-type monotone energy and can be less singular than either flow alone.

Where it stands

The DeTurck trick is now routine for every geometric flow with a gauge symmetry. Current work on short-time existence concerns rough or non-compact initial data, manifolds with boundary, and flows where the gauge is harder to fix. For harmonic maps themselves, see the survey below; the feed also includes Ricci flow coupled to other fields.

If you are new to this

Foundational papers

The papers the rest of the topic builds on, in reading order. Titles open the paper.

  1. 1964
    Harmonic Mappings of Riemannian Manifolds James Eells, J. H. Sampson · American Journal of Mathematics, vol. 86 Eells–Sampson: the harmonic map heat flow into non-positively curved targets. DOI 10.2307/2373037
  2. 1975
    Harmonic Maps of Manifolds with Boundary Richard S. Hamilton · Lecture Notes in Mathematics Hamilton: harmonic maps of manifolds with boundary. DOI 10.1007/bfb0087227
  3. 1985
    On the evolution of harmonic mappings of Riemannian surfaces Michael Struwe · Commentarii Mathematici Helvetici, vol. 60 Struwe: the flow from surfaces, with finitely many bubbling points. DOI 10.1007/bf02567432
  4. 1983
    Deforming metrics in the direction of their Ricci tensors Dennis M. DeTurck · Journal of Differential Geometry, vol. 18 DeTurck: the DeTurck trick and short-time existence of Ricci flow. DOI 10.4310/jdg/1214509286
  5. 1992
    Finite-time blow-up of the heat flow of harmonic maps from surfaces Kung-Ching Chang, Wei Yue Ding, Rugang Ye · Journal of Differential Geometry, vol. 36 Chang–Ding–Ye: finite-time blow-up of the harmonic map flow from surfaces. DOI 10.4310/jdg/1214448751
  6. 2005
    Uniqueness of the Ricci Flow on Complete Noncompact Manifolds Bing-Long Chen, Xi-Ping Zhu · arXiv:math/0505447 Chen–Zhu: uniqueness on complete non-compact manifolds, via harmonic map flow. PDFarXiv:math/0505447
  7. 2009
    Ricci flow coupled with harmonic map flow Reto Müller · Ann. Sci. Ec. Norm. Sup. 45, fascicule 1 (2012), 101-142 Müller: Ricci flow coupled with harmonic map flow. PDFarXiv:0912.2907

Where to start reading

Surveys & books

Longer, gentler routes in, and the references specialists keep on their desks.

  1. 2008
    The Analysis of Harmonic Maps and Their Heat Flows Fanghua Lin, Changyou Wang · WORLD SCIENTIFIC Lin–Wang: *The Analysis of Harmonic Maps and Their Heat Flows*. DOI 10.1142/6679

If you follow the research

Latest papers · 54 papers

The newest 20, updated every weekday from arXiv. Follow this topic with its own RSS feed, or see who writes most on it.

math.DGWider flowsarXiv:2610.25745

Combinatorial Calabi flows on infinitely triangulated surfaces

Yuerong Bian, Xu Xu

We study the combinatorial Calabi flow associated with vertex scalings on infinitely triangulated surfaces with piecewise Euclidean and piecewise hyperbolic metrics. Under the assumptions of uniformly bounded vertex degree and an -uniformly nondegenerate initial metric, we establish short-time existence of smooth solutions and prove uniqueness among solutions that are continuous in the norm.

math.DGarXiv:2610.02519

Almost Hermitian geometry and generalized Ricci flow

Anna Fino, Julieth Saavedra

We study almost Hermitian manifolds whose lowered Nijenhuis tensor is totally skew-symmetric and whose characteristic (Bismut) torsion is closed, the almost-SKT condition. This extends the SKT (pluriclosed) condition beyond the integrable setting. For a fixed almost complex structure, these constraints are linear in the metric. We introduce an overdetermined ellipticity condition which, on compact manifolds, makes the admissible infinitesimal deformation space finite-dimensional and yields short-time existence for a constrained Bismut–Ricci flow. In real dimension six, almost-SKT structures satisfy a dichotomy: either the almost complex structure is integrable, or the skew Nijenhuis tensor is nowhere vanishing with constant norm and the Bismut Ricci form vanishes. Hence, on compact non-integrable almost-SKT six-manifolds, the constrained Bismut–Ricci flow is stationary. In dimension eight, ellipticity always fails, while in higher dimensions Nijenhuis rigidity holds on an open dense locus. In arbitrary dimension, we characterize when total skew-symmetry of the lowered Nijenhuis tensor determines the compatible metric pointwise up to scale. On compact manifolds, with closed torsion, this implies uniqueness of the almost-SKT metric up to scaling; the constrained Bismut–Ricci flow is then an explicit homothetic solution. We also relate this flow to generalized Ricci flow and characterize the infinitesimal obstruction to lifting the evolution when the almost complex structure varies. Finally, we construct non-integrable almost-SKT structures with nowhere vanishing Nijenhuis tensor and non-flat characteristic connection on compact six-manifolds, including and . In these families, the metric is fixed and the compatible almost complex structures form an -family. These structures have vanishing Bismut Ricci form and are therefore almost-CYT.

math.DGarXiv:2609.37549

Smoothing polyhedral spaces via Ricci flow

Richard H. Bamler, Esther Cabezas-Rivas

We prove Petrunin's smoothing conjecture in all dimensions: every compact Euclidean polyhedral space without boundary and with nonnegative Alexandrov curvature is a Gromov-Hausdorff limit of smooth Riemannian orbifolds with geometrically nonnegative curvature. More strongly, the approximating metrics are positive-time slices of a single orbifold Ricci flow whose metric initial condition is the given polyhedral space. The proof rests on a new short-time existence and regularization theory for Ricci flow that, under two-sided volume bounds and a generalized segment inequality, replaces pointwise lower curvature control by small scale-invariant integral control of the defect from a preserved curvature cone. Although it allows arbitrarily large pointwise violations, this theory yields an existence time and positive-time curvature estimates independent of the initial upper curvature bound. As a further application, it gives rigidity consequences for manifolds with small integral curvature defect.

math.DGarXiv:2608.21502

A Lean Formalization of Hamilton's Three-Manifold Theorem

Bennett Chow, Yuan Liao, Ziyang Qin

We describe a Lean formalization of Hamilton's 1982 theorem on closed, connected three-manifolds with positive Ricci curvature. The development contains a short-time existence theorem for Ricci flow and substantial geometric-analysis infrastructure: Riemannian tensor calculus, the Levi–Civita connection, Ricci-flow evolution equations, scalar and tensor maximum principles, three-dimensional curvature algebra, preservation of Ricci pinching, and Hamilton's improved pinching estimate. The formalization follows an alternative blow-up route, rather than Hamilton's original normalized-flow proof. Its time-uniform short-time existence, maximal continuation, no-local-collapsing, and Cheeger–Gromov–Hamilton compactness pipelines have been formalized and are included in the artifact, while we give only a brief account of these companion developments and record the interfaces and consequences used by the Hamilton argument; a detailed exposition of their full constructions is deferred to the second author's forthcoming thesis. We interweave representative Lean declarations with their mathematical meaning and record the status and provenance of every major component. All source-level status claims are tied to the source release identified below.

math.DGarXiv:2607.26240

Ricci Solitons on the Lie Group and Applications

Mohammed El Amine Mekki, Ahmed Mohammed Cherif

In this paper, we study Ricci solitons on the three-dimensional solvable Lie group equipped with a left-invariant Riemannian metric, viewed as a generalization of the classical geometry. We investigate harmonic maps, harmonic sections, and geodesic curves, including the geodesic properties of the integral curves of the Ricci soliton vector field. We also characterize harmonic linear maps from into Euclidean spaces.

math.DGWider flowsv2arXiv:2607.25691

Combinatorial Yamabe flow on infinitely triangulated hyperbolic surfaces

Yuerong Bian, Xu Xu

We study the combinatorial Yamabe flow on infinitely triangulated surfaces with piecewise hyperbolic metrics. Under the assumptions of uniformly bounded vertex degree and an -uniformly nondegenerate initial metric, we establish the short-time existence and uniqueness of smooth solutions to the combinatorial Yamabe flow. To address the potential degeneration of triangles along the evolution, we introduce an extended flow with generalized curvature, and establish the global existence of solutions to the extended flow.Furthermore, under an integrability condition, we establish the uniqueness of solutions to this extended flow, which follows from the stability property of the solutions. These results provide a local well-posedness theory for the hyperbolic combinatorial Yamabe flow on infinitely triangulated surfaces.

math.DGWider flowsarXiv:2607.23584

Infinite Combinatorial Yamabe Flows in Three Dimensions

Bohao Ji

In this paper, we study three-dimensional combinatorial Yamabe flows on locally finite infinite triangulations in Euclidean and hyperbolic background geometries. Under suitable non-degeneracy and bounded-degree assumptions, we establish the short-time existence and uniqueness of the original flows. We further introduce the extended flows by using the continuous extension of solid angles, and prove long-time existence for both extended flows under suitable initial assumptions.

cs.ITv3arXiv:2606.19493

Ricci flow for the Bures–Helstrom qubit metric

Andrew Lesniewski

The Bures–Helstrom metric is the minimal monotone Riemannian metric on the state space of a qubit. With the quantum Fisher normalization used here, it identifies the Bloch ball with a geodesic hemisphere of the unit round three–sphere. We describe its Ricci flow explicitly. In a general rotationally symmetric gauge the flow is a coupled system for the radial lapse and warping factor; a single scalar equation appears only after a Hamilton–DeTurck gauge choice. In the corresponding moving DeTurck frame the squared warping function satisfies the linear forced heat equation \beginequation* D_tΨ=Ψ_ss-2, \endequation* while the fixed-lapse coordinate form contains the associated transport term. Since the Bures–Helstrom metric is Einstein, the geometric flow itself is the homothetic shrinker \beginequation* g(t)=(1-4t)g_BH, \endequation* with scalar curvature and extinction time . Thus the metric remains inside the monotone cone for all and leaves the cone of nondegenerate Riemannian metrics only through the collapsed limit. We also record the volume–normalized flow, for which the Bures–Helstrom metric is a fixed point. Its linearization is the shifted round–sphere Laplacian , with spectrum \beginequation* σ_\ell=-(\ell-1)(\ell+3), \endequation* and spectral gap after removal of the scaling mode.

math.NAWider flowsarXiv:2605.21445

Error analysis of a finite element scheme for parametric mean curvature flow based on the DeTurck trick

Klaus Deckelnick, Vanessa Styles

The paper is concerned with the error analysis of a numerical scheme for the approximation of parametric mean curvature flow. The scheme we study is based on a reparametrization using the DeTurck trick and was proposed by Elliott and Fritz in [15]. In the semidiscrete case, for a spatial discretization by finite elements of order we prove an optimal -error estimate for the position vector. We present numerical experiments that confirm this error bound and demonstrate that the scheme has good properties with respect to the distribution of mesh points as already observed in [15].

math.DGarXiv:2604.15198

Integrable Deformations and Stability of the Ricci Flow

Maxwell Stolarski, Alex Waldron

We provide a comparatively simple proof of the dynamical stability of Ricci flow near a linearly stable Ricci-flat ALE metric with integrable deformations. Our proof relies on the equivalence between integrability and an "almost-orthogonality" property of the Ricci-DeTurck tensor, allowing us to analyze the latter directly. We obtain our main results in weighted Holder spaces and then show how to recover the -stability theorems of Deruelle-Kroncke and Kroncke-Petersen.

math.DGarXiv:2603.22834

The Ricci-DeTurck flow on complete manifolds

Jing-Bin Cai, Bing Wang

Based on the framework of Koch-Lamm and tensor heat kernel estimates, we obtain a uniform proof of the short-time existence, uniqueness, and continuous dependence for Ricci flows starting from a complete Riemannian metric with bounded curvature. A new ingredient is an effective continuous dependence estimate without the assumption of injectivity radius lower bound.

math.DGarXiv:2603.08969

On Ricci Solitons and Harmonic Vector Fields in the Thurston Geometry

Halima Boukhari, Hadjer Okbani, Ahmed Mohammed Cherif

In this paper, we consider a left-invariant Riemannian metric on the Lie group . We classify Ricci solitons on and show that all such solitons are expanding and non-gradient. Moreover, we study the existence of harmonic maps from compact Riemannian manifolds into . Finally, we characterize a class of harmonic vector fields on .

math.DGWider flowsarXiv:2602.07989

Existence of the classical solution to the fractional mean curvature flow with capillary-type boundary conditions

Linlin Fan, Peibiao Zhao

Wang, Weng and Xia[Math. Ann. 388 (2024), no. 2] studied a mean curvature type flow for the smooth, embedded capillary hypersurfaces with a constant contact angle and confirmed the existence of solutions by the standard PDE theory. In the present paper, we study a fractional mean curvature flow for -regular hypersurfaces with a capillary-type boundary condition and obtain the short time existence by the fixed point argument.

math.DGarXiv:2601.05210

Ricci-harmonic flow of and Spin(7)-structures

Shubham Dwivedi

We introduce and study a new general flow of -structures which we call the Ricci-harmonic flow of -structures. The flow is the coupling of the Ricci flow of underlying metrics and the isometric flow of -structures, but we also provide explicit lower order in the torsion terms. The lower order terms and the flow are obtained by analyzing the second order term in the Taylor series expansion of -structures in normal coordinates. As such, the Ricci-harmonic flow described in the paper can be interpreted as the "heat equation" for -structures. The lower order terms allow us to prove that the stationary points of the Ricci-harmonic flow are exactly torsion-free -structures on compact manifolds. We study various analytic and geometric properties of the flow. We show that the flow has short-time existence and uniqueness on compact manifolds starting with an arbitrary -structure and prove global Shi-type estimates. We also prove a modified local Shi-type estimates for the flow which assume bounds on the initial derivatives of the Riemann curvature tensor and the torsion but give uniform bounds on these quantities for all times. We prove a compactness theorem for the solutions of the flow and use it to prove that the Ricci-harmonic flow exists as long as the velocity of the flow remains bounded. We also study Ricci-harmonic solitons where we prove that there are no compact expanding solitons and the only steady solitons are torsion-free. We derive an analog of Hamilton's identity for gradient Ricci-harmonic solitons and prove some integral identities for the solitons. Finally, we prove a version of the Taylor series expansion for Spin(7)-structures and use it to derive the Ricci-harmonic flow of Spin(7)-structures.

math.DGarXiv:2601.01863

A Spinorial Perelman's Functional: Critical Points and Gradient Flow

Tsz-Kiu Aaron Chow, Frederick Tsz-Ho Fong

In this article, we introduce an energy functional on closed Riemannian spin manifolds which unifies Perelman's W- and F-functionals, Baldauf-Ouzch's E-functional, and Dirchlet energy for spinors. We compute its first variation formula, and show that its critical points under natural constraints are twisted Ricci solitons and eigen-spinsors of the weighted Dirac operator. We introduce a negative L^2-gradient flow of this functional, and establish its short-time existence and uniqueness via contraction mapping methods.

math.DGWider flowsarXiv:2512.02451

Twisted Calabi functional and twisted Calabi flow

Jie He, Haozhao Li

This paper investigates the twisted Calabi functional and the associated twisted Calabi flow on compact Kähler manifolds. Our main contributions are threefold: first, we establish the convexity of the twisted Calabi functional at its critical points; second, we prove the short-time existence of the twisted Calabi flow; and third, we demonstrate the stability of this flow in the neighborhood of twisted constant scalar curvature Kähler metrics. These results provide an analytic foundation for studying the twisted Calabi flow and resolve questions about its local behavior.

math.DGv2arXiv:2511.21055

Flows of conformally coclosed -structures with dilaton

Spiro Karigiannis, Sébastien Picard, Caleb Suan

We study flows of -structures guided by the principle of dimensional reduction: natural geometric flows in -geometry reduce to natural flows in complex geometry. Our main examples are the -Laplacian coflow, which lifts the Kähler–Ricci flow, and a 7-dimensional lift of the anomaly flow on complex threefolds. The -lift of the anomaly flow deforms conformally coclosed -structures. We compare the -anomaly flow to the -Laplacian coflow, and investigate short-time existence and fixed points.

math.DGarXiv:2510.23239

Mean curvature flow into an ambient Riemannian manifold evolving by Ricci flow coupled with harmonic map heat flow

José N. V. Gomes, Matheus Hudson, Carlos M. de Sousa

The main objective of this article is to study the mean curvature flow into an ambient compact smooth manifold M with boundary and with a Riemannian metric that evolves by a self-similar solution of the Ricci flow coupled with the harmonic map heat flow of a map from M to a Riemannian manifold N. In this context, we address a functional associated with this flow and calculate its variation along parameters that preserve the weighted volume measure. An extension of Hamilton's differential Harnack expression appears by considering the boundary of M evolving by mean curvature flow, which must vanish on the gradient steady soliton case. Next, we obtain a Huisken monotonicity-type formula for the mean curvature flow in the proposed background. We also show how to construct a family of mean curvature solitons and establish a characterization of such a family.

math.DGarXiv:2509.00188

On the stability of Ricci flow on hyperbolic 3-manifolds of finite volume

Ruojing Jiang, Franco Vargas Pallete

On a hyperbolic 3-manifold of finite volume, we prove that if the initial metric is sufficiently close to the hyperbolic metric , then the normalized Ricci-DeTurck flow exists for all time and converges exponentially fast to in a weighted Hölder norm. A key ingredient of our approach is the application of interpolation theory. Furthermore, this result is a valuable tool for investigating minimal surface entropy, which quantifies the growth rate of the number of closed minimal surfaces in terms of genus. We explore this in [17].

All 54 papers on Harmonic maps & DeTurck trick, by year